Album Review

Kamelot - SilverthornKamelot – Silverthorn

Here is a band that kept cropping up as I followed my longstanding favourite power metal band Firewind but I’ve neglected to actually check them out! So in preparation for this review I checked out their back catalogue and I must say that even though I’ve only been a fan now for a short time I fully understand how devastating it is to have lost long standing powerful vocalist Roy Khan, from what I can tell though Khan had become very ill and left for health and personal reasons which is understandable. That however led to then inevitably searching for a new vocalist to then release their first album without Khan since 1998! Changing a vocalist is an extremely difficult transition for fans to get onboard with as once the voice of a band has been established it is incredibly hard to replace, I have seen it too many times be a bands rapid undoing.

A positive sign was that they brought in an extremely talented vocalist in Tommy Karevik (the voice of Seventh Wonder) who has demonstrated he can keep within close range to the usual vocal lines we’ve become accustomed in Kamelot fashion but hasn’t gone as far as to become Khan’s vocal double, he is also credited with writing credits on this album which when listening to the material is incredible as it keeps true to the longstanding style in which the band has prided itself for years. The great thing about the material is that it’s like a time machine back to a band that was in its pinnacle moment of defining itself before the ascension of fighting for survival, thinking more “Ghost Opera” than “Poetry For The Poisoned” in terms of structure. The song’s really suck you in as they portray to you a story that you can’t forget due to the infectious nature the sound emits,

Karevik has held himself back this time to fit what the band required of him, but I don’t feel that it will last and rightly so because a vocalist has his own voice and should push it as far as it will reach, with his progressive background he could really give future Kamelot a huge push into realms they may never dreamt of approaching. As far as this release goes though they’ve continued to give us a quality that is lost on many other bands these days and is as consistently fantastic as ever.

4.5/5

Review by James Webb

 Band Members

Thomas Youngblood
Casey Grillo
Oliver Palotai
Sean Tibbetts
Tommy Karevik
 Track Listing

1. Manus Dei
2. Sacrimony (Angel of Afterlife)
3. Ashes to Ashes
4. Torn
5. Song for Jolee
6. Veritas
7. My Confession
8. Silverthorn
9. Falling Like The Fahrenheit
10. Solitaire
11. Prodigal Son
12. Continuum

 Band Related Links
Kamelot Facebook
 Review Score Code
- Top Cheese
- Brilliant
- Pretty damn good
- Ok I guess
- What Was That?